Enough Said (2013)

An ensemble movie consisting of a divorced couple with a self obsessed daughter, a divorcee who has a confident and uncomplicated approach to life whose daughter is living with her and preparing to leave home for college. There is also a couple, friends of the divorcee, one who is a psycho therapist, who are having a conflict with their employee, a Spanish maid, who they cannot tolerate for her strange habit of replacing strange objects in the wrong place.

The story relates to the divorcee, played by Julia Louis-Dreyfus, a self employed masseuse who visits her clients, carrying a portable massage bed, in their own homes. She is also caring for her daughter who is in the throes of letting go and moving on to college in another place. The daughter also has a friend who seeks to make a friend of her mother. In the process of making that friendship, given advice that her friends mother should not really have been giving and also giving space and hope for her own independence which also she should not really have been giving. The divorcee’s daughter is able to put this to her mother very effectively at the end of the film. But I digress. At a party, our divorcee meets a woman who engages her for a home visit massage. At the same party she also meets a man who obviously takes a shine to her. She is totally unaware that this man is divorced from the woman who has just engaged her for a home visit. Through a friend, the divorced man, who is played by the late excellent James Gandolfini, arranges a date. They slowly hit it off. Later in the story the divorcee discovers from the woman at the party, who she is now visiting regularly and becoming friends with, in a roundabout way that the man the divorcee is dating is this woman’s ex-husband.

Are you still with me ? Don’t worry. It is not a complicated story or film to watch and follow. But just try explaining it to your friend. Which is why many reviewers who have written about this film, have been challenged to sell this film to its wider audience. There is only one spoiler which isn’t spoiling the film – that is discovering that the man you are dating was once married to the woman that you are offering a massage service to and who has been confiding in you her dislikes of his personality and the things that she was irritated by.

How do you let on ? Why don’t you let on. This is not completely explored but it is the impact of not doing so that is the crux of the story. Louis-Dreyfus misses her opportunity and at a dinner party she even tests out the personality traits that so detest Gandolfini’s ex-wife. She does this in a heartbreakingly unkind way.

It is the relationship between Louis-Dreyfus and Gandolfini that dominates the story. It has some haunting one liners. After falling out Louis- Dreyfus goes round to try and salvage the friendship, to be rebuffed – “You broke my heart, and I’m too old for that now.”

Dreyfus’s daughter, played by Tracey Fairaway, emphasises the need to be owned and loved. When she leaves at the airport to go to to college, both Dreyfus and her ex-husband are there to send her off and they are together on their way out, arms around one another – “We made a really good person there”.

The film plays out with Dreyfus and Ganolfini willing their relationship to get back on track and we are left with an optimistic hop at the end.

It is a humorous, not funny, film with characters that are well cast. They gel so well that you can imagine that it might have fun to have been on set with them. The story is authentic and believable and draws you into the relationships and willing the characters to get it sorted Which they sort of do.

Goodness knows what the Americans think of us in the UK. At one point, after dropping her daughter off at school, Dreyfus shouts at another student to pick her litter up. “Pick your rubbish up, your’e not British.!” 

Sunshine on Leith (2013)

Cinema as blissful entertainment, like eating a chocolate bar all by one’s self, does not offer a great deal of choice these days. Action, adventure, crime and drama dominate, as they always have. The era of the musical seemed to be over until Mamma Mia came out and filled every seat for weeks and months with audiences attending in fancy dress or going as a group to sing the songs. Even men who had been grudgingly taken along left the cinema with grins on their faces. Then next and from a completely different genre arrives Les Miserables. This was the antidote to the party film and also a challenging film for a repeat viewing. It was a film with a tortuous story and some memorable music that was difficult to sing to.

Mamma Mia was not a great film. It had a loose story, awful singing, and it won a raspberry nomination. Sunshine on Leith is nothing like this – even someone’s awful singing is put to good use in a memorable dance scene.

Two men return from serving in the army where thay have been in action in Afghanistan. One anticipates returning to his girlfriend, the other anticipates finding one. They get fitted up and the story leads us to the parents of one of them, played by Peter Mullan and Jane Horrocks. A letter from the past and a funeral lead us down the path of a love interest from twenty years ago with a resulting, unknown to Mullan, daughter who is now an adult. This is not a shallow story of loss and love but a story that most people in its audiences might relate to. It is honest and carries with it the cloak of integrity that many theatre rep companies offer to their audiences. Indeed, this story was developed, written and performed by Dundee Rep. Company.

The songs ? As Mamma Mia was based upon the Abba songbook, so Sunshine on Leith was based upon the songbook of The Proclaimers, a Scottish group whose canon of work are the spirit of the 1980’s and 1990’s and reflect the vibrant energy of a changing nation as industry slowly disappears. They sang songs of love, loss and yearning, giving hope and anthems to many as they grew up. The play’s author has cleverly woven the story around the songs and they enable some excellent set scenes that can only bring a smile to your face.

For me, the Proclaimers prove my Leonard Cohen theory. Their songs are sometimes better sung and more effectively delivered by others. Never having enjoyed Cohen’s songs when he sang them, I was impressed years ago when Jennifer Warne sang them in Famous Blue Raincoat, showing how beautiful the lyrics could be. This theory of auteurs not being the best singers in the world is evidenced in Sunshine on Leith.

As you would expect with a classical film musical, we have a story that breaks your heart, makes you smile and offers set musical pieces that carry the story along. Three memorable scenes worth pointing out are the anniversary party where the band strikes up Oh Jean for Mullan to serenade his wife. He cannot sing but the band’s playing and guests dancing to his rendition are great fun. Jane Horrocks singing the title song is sweet and tender while the closing flash mob style dance routine will have you smiling all the way home.

Blue Jasmine (2013

Nostalgia has a habit of clouding our memories with attractive images. The subconscious filters out the bad times or tries to amend them with the thoughts of what if. The famous line from On the Waterfront, ‘I could have been a contender’ comes to mind when we meet Cate Blanchet’s character………… She is frequently recalling what it is she has lost and instead of ‘could have been……’ she had been a contender. Until, that is, she discovered that her imprisoned banker husband was a fraudulent crook.

The reason for stating this is that in twenty five years time when young people look back at the ‘teens it will be a challenge for them to recall the difference between the good and the bad times when the only possible chance for many to own their own home will be to inherit their parents house. How many will reflect with goodwill to the lack of financial opportunity that most folk in the UK and US have had to experience? Blue Jasmine is a story of our times. The zeitgeist is one of hope and a struggle for survival.

Cate Blanchett plays Jasmine. She has lost everything when we meet her talking to a woman on a plane. We then realise she is talking at her because when the woman’s husband greets her at the luggage carousel and asks her who the woman talking to her was, she says ‘I don’t know but she wouldn’t stop talking to me.’ This was a clever entrance vehicle to the story and it is one of two moments when the audience that I was in, laughed. The other was when Jasmine’s sisters children, in a diner with Jasmine for a treat ask her why she keeps talking to herself. Both these moments were poignant and clear indicators that people near her were thinking she was odd. The laughter was nervous.

Jasmine has fled to her sisters house in California. She is penniless but her tastes and expectations remain the same. Her sister Ginger, played by Sally Hawkins, is bringing up two young boys by herself after separating from her husband. We discover that in a previous time that she and her husband have lost a considerable windfall of money in one of Jasmine’s husbands fraudulent investments. Ginger is now with a new boyfriend and Jasmine tries to corrupt this new relationship.

The story shows us Jasmine’s downfall in the form of a spiral. At each level downwards we see a facet or an action that she is using to grip onto for safety. But in doing so it becomes a catalyst for another person’s downfall, corruption or temporary destruction. We can see the pointers for this in the lies that she has to spin to survive. She has nothing, why should others be better off than she or have life worth living when she does not.

She is also prey to other male speculators who want her. One is a lusty dentist who advances she fends off. The other, a wealthy diplomat who she wants but cannot allow the truth to come between them. When it does, the rejection becomes a catalyst for her breakdown.

We finally see her on a park bench talking to herself again. She could have been a contender but there are only so many breakdowns and traumas a girl can take.

This is not a hurtful story. We are pleased that her sister Ginger gets it together again. The director, Woody Allen, does not wish Jasmine harm and he has created a web of sympathy that only those who have been the victims of austerity might share.